{"study":"Ahluwalia 2006","x.nrt":53,"n.nrt":378,"x.ctrl":42,"n.ctrl":377,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Areechon 1988","x.nrt":56,"n.nrt":99,"x.ctrl":37,"n.ctrl":101,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Blondal 1989","x.nrt":30,"n.nrt":92,"x.ctrl":22,"n.ctrl":90,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Br Thor Society 1983","x.nrt":39,"n.nrt":410,"x.ctrl":111,"n.ctrl":1208,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Campbell 1987","x.nrt":13,"n.nrt":424,"x.ctrl":9,"n.ctrl":412,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Campbell 1991","x.nrt":21,"n.nrt":107,"x.ctrl":21,"n.ctrl":105,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Clavel 1985","x.nrt":24,"n.nrt":205,"x.ctrl":6,"n.ctrl":222,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Clavel-Chapelon 1992","x.nrt":47,"n.nrt":481,"x.ctrl":42,"n.ctrl":515,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Cooper 2005","x.nrt":17,"n.nrt":146,"x.ctrl":15,"n.ctrl":147,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Fagerstrom 1982","x.nrt":30,"n.nrt":50,"x.ctrl":23,"n.ctrl":50,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Fagerstrom 1984","x.nrt":28,"n.nrt":96,"x.ctrl":5,"n.ctrl":49,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Fee 1982","x.nrt":23,"n.nrt":180,"x.ctrl":15,"n.ctrl":172,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Fortmann 1995","x.nrt":110,"n.nrt":552,"x.ctrl":84,"n.ctrl":522,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Garcia 1989","x.nrt":21,"n.nrt":68,"x.ctrl":5,"n.ctrl":38,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Garvey 2000","x.nrt":75,"n.nrt":405,"x.ctrl":17,"n.ctrl":203,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Gilbert 1989","x.nrt":11,"n.nrt":112,"x.ctrl":9,"n.ctrl":111,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Gross 1995","x.nrt":37,"n.nrt":131,"x.ctrl":6,"n.ctrl":46,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Hall 1985","x.nrt":18,"n.nrt":41,"x.ctrl":10,"n.ctrl":36,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Hall 1987","x.nrt":30,"n.nrt":71,"x.ctrl":14,"n.ctrl":68,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Hall 1996","x.nrt":24,"n.nrt":98,"x.ctrl":28,"n.ctrl":103,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Harackiewicz 1988","x.nrt":12,"n.nrt":99,"x.ctrl":7,"n.ctrl":52,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Herrera 1995","x.nrt":30,"n.nrt":76,"x.ctrl":13,"n.ctrl":78,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Hjalmarson 1984","x.nrt":31,"n.nrt":106,"x.ctrl":16,"n.ctrl":100,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Huber 1988","x.nrt":13,"n.nrt":54,"x.ctrl":11,"n.ctrl":60,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Hughes 1989a","x.nrt":23,"n.nrt":210,"x.ctrl":6,"n.ctrl":105,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Hughes 1990","x.nrt":15,"n.nrt":59,"x.ctrl":5,"n.ctrl":19,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Jamrozik 1984","x.nrt":10,"n.nrt":101,"x.ctrl":8,"n.ctrl":99,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Jarvis 1982","x.nrt":22,"n.nrt":58,"x.ctrl":9,"n.ctrl":58,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Jensen 1991","x.nrt":49,"n.nrt":211,"x.ctrl":19,"n.ctrl":82,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Killen 1984","x.nrt":16,"n.nrt":44,"x.ctrl":6,"n.ctrl":20,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Killen 1990","x.nrt":129,"n.nrt":600,"x.ctrl":112,"n.ctrl":617,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Llivina 1988","x.nrt":61,"n.nrt":113,"x.ctrl":28,"n.ctrl":103,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Malcolm 1980","x.nrt":6,"n.nrt":73,"x.ctrl":3,"n.ctrl":121,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"McGovern 1992","x.nrt":51,"n.nrt":146,"x.ctrl":40,"n.ctrl":127,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Moolchan 2005","x.nrt":8,"n.nrt":46,"x.ctrl":2,"n.ctrl":40,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Mori 1992","x.nrt":30,"n.nrt":178,"x.ctrl":22,"n.ctrl":186,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Nakamura 1990","x.nrt":13,"n.nrt":30,"x.ctrl":5,"n.ctrl":30,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Nebot 1992","x.nrt":5,"n.nrt":106,"x.ctrl":13,"n.ctrl":319,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Niaura 1994","x.nrt":5,"n.nrt":84,"x.ctrl":4,"n.ctrl":89,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Niaura 1999","x.nrt":1,"n.nrt":31,"x.ctrl":2,"n.ctrl":31,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Ockene 1991","x.nrt":40,"n.nrt":402,"x.ctrl":33,"n.ctrl":420,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Oncken 2008","x.nrt":11,"n.nrt":100,"x.ctrl":9,"n.ctrl":94,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Page 1986","x.nrt":9,"n.nrt":93,"x.ctrl":13,"n.ctrl":182,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Pirie 1992","x.nrt":75,"n.nrt":206,"x.ctrl":50,"n.ctrl":211,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Puska 1979","x.nrt":29,"n.nrt":116,"x.ctrl":21,"n.ctrl":113,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Richmond 1993","x.nrt":17,"n.nrt":200,"x.ctrl":14,"n.ctrl":150,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Roto 1987","x.nrt":19,"n.nrt":54,"x.ctrl":7,"n.ctrl":60,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Russell 1983","x.nrt":81,"n.nrt":729,"x.ctrl":78,"n.ctrl":1377,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Schneider 1983a","x.nrt":9,"n.nrt":30,"x.ctrl":6,"n.ctrl":30,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Schneider 1983b","x.nrt":1,"n.nrt":13,"x.ctrl":3,"n.ctrl":23,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Segnan 1991","x.nrt":22,"n.nrt":294,"x.ctrl":37,"n.ctrl":629,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Shiffman 2009 (2 mg)","x.nrt":24,"n.nrt":819,"x.ctrl":9,"n.ctrl":817,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Shiffman 2009 (4 mg)","x.nrt":101,"n.nrt":830,"x.ctrl":24,"n.ctrl":831,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Tonnesen 1988","x.nrt":23,"n.nrt":60,"x.ctrl":12,"n.ctrl":53,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Villa 1999","x.nrt":11,"n.nrt":21,"x.ctrl":10,"n.ctrl":26,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Zelman 1992","x.nrt":23,"n.nrt":58,"x.ctrl":18,"n.ctrl":58,"treatment":"gum"}
{"study":"Abelin 1989","x.nrt":17,"n.nrt":100,"x.ctrl":11,"n.ctrl":99,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Ahluwalia 1998","x.nrt":35,"n.nrt":205,"x.ctrl":24,"n.ctrl":205,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Anthenelli 2016","x.nrt":320,"n.nrt":2038,"x.ctrl":191,"n.ctrl":2035,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Buchkremer 1988","x.nrt":11,"n.nrt":42,"x.ctrl":16,"n.ctrl":89,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Campbell 1996","x.nrt":24,"n.nrt":115,"x.ctrl":17,"n.ctrl":119,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Cinciripini 1996","x.nrt":12,"n.nrt":32,"x.ctrl":7,"n.ctrl":32,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Coleman 2012","x.nrt":49,"n.nrt":521,"x.ctrl":40,"n.ctrl":529,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Cummins 2016","x.nrt":44,"n.nrt":637,"x.ctrl":38,"n.ctrl":633,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Cunningham 2016","x.nrt":14,"n.nrt":500,"x.ctrl":5,"n.ctrl":499,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Daughton 1991","x.nrt":28,"n.nrt":106,"x.ctrl":4,"n.ctrl":52,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Daughton 1998","x.nrt":25,"n.nrt":184,"x.ctrl":16,"n.ctrl":185,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Davidson 1998","x.nrt":33,"n.nrt":401,"x.ctrl":16,"n.ctrl":401,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Ehrsam 1991","x.nrt":7,"n.nrt":56,"x.ctrl":2,"n.ctrl":56,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Fiore 1994a","x.nrt":15,"n.nrt":44,"x.ctrl":9,"n.ctrl":44,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Fiore 1994b","x.nrt":10,"n.nrt":57,"x.ctrl":4,"n.ctrl":55,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Gallagher 2007","x.nrt":1,"n.nrt":60,"x.ctrl":4,"n.ctrl":60,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Glavas 2003a","x.nrt":13,"n.nrt":56,"x.ctrl":9,"n.ctrl":56,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Glavas 2003b","x.nrt":29,"n.nrt":80,"x.ctrl":12,"n.ctrl":80,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Hays 1999","x.nrt":62,"n.nrt":636,"x.ctrl":14,"n.ctrl":322,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Heydari 2012","x.nrt":23,"n.nrt":92,"x.ctrl":6,"n.ctrl":91,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Hughes 1999","x.nrt":171,"n.nrt":779,"x.ctrl":34,"n.ctrl":260,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Hughes 2003","x.nrt":13,"n.nrt":61,"x.ctrl":8,"n.ctrl":54,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Hurt 1990","x.nrt":8,"n.nrt":31,"x.ctrl":6,"n.ctrl":31,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Hurt 1994","x.nrt":33,"n.nrt":120,"x.ctrl":17,"n.ctrl":120,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"ICRF 1994","x.nrt":76,"n.nrt":842,"x.ctrl":53,"n.ctrl":844,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Jorenby 1999","x.nrt":24,"n.nrt":244,"x.ctrl":9,"n.ctrl":160,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Joseph 1996","x.nrt":29,"n.nrt":294,"x.ctrl":35,"n.ctrl":290,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Killen 1997","x.nrt":23,"n.nrt":212,"x.ctrl":21,"n.ctrl":212,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Kornitzer 1995","x.nrt":19,"n.nrt":150,"x.ctrl":10,"n.ctrl":75,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Lerman 2015","x.nrt":69,"n.nrt":418,"x.ctrl":50,"n.ctrl":408,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Lewis 1998","x.nrt":6,"n.nrt":62,"x.ctrl":7,"n.ctrl":123,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Moolchan 2005","x.nrt":9,"n.nrt":34,"x.ctrl":2,"n.ctrl":40,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"NCT00534404","x.nrt":194,"n.nrt":830,"x.ctrl":109,"n.ctrl":828,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Oncken 2007","x.nrt":19,"n.nrt":57,"x.ctrl":28,"n.ctrl":95,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Otero 2006","x.nrt":193,"n.nrt":597,"x.ctrl":122,"n.ctrl":602,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Paoletti 1996","x.nrt":15,"n.nrt":60,"x.ctrl":4,"n.ctrl":60,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Perng 1998","x.nrt":9,"n.nrt":30,"x.ctrl":3,"n.ctrl":32,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Piper 2009","x.nrt":90,"n.nrt":262,"x.ctrl":8,"n.ctrl":37,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Prapavessis 2007","x.nrt":13,"n.nrt":59,"x.ctrl":7,"n.ctrl":62,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Richmond 1994","x.nrt":29,"n.nrt":153,"x.ctrl":14,"n.ctrl":152,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Sachs 1993","x.nrt":28,"n.nrt":113,"x.ctrl":10,"n.ctrl":107,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Scherphof 2014","x.nrt":6,"n.nrt":136,"x.ctrl":8,"n.ctrl":129,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Stapleton 1995","x.nrt":77,"n.nrt":800,"x.ctrl":19,"n.ctrl":400,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Sonderskov 1997","x.nrt":20,"n.nrt":251,"x.ctrl":14,"n.ctrl":267,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"TNSG 1991","x.nrt":111,"n.nrt":537,"x.ctrl":31,"n.ctrl":271,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Tuisku 2016","x.nrt":19,"n.nrt":94,"x.ctrl":13,"n.ctrl":86,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Tonnesen 1991","x.nrt":24,"n.nrt":145,"x.ctrl":6,"n.ctrl":144,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Tonnesen 2000","x.nrt":9,"n.nrt":104,"x.ctrl":2,"n.ctrl":109,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Ward 2013","x.nrt":17,"n.nrt":134,"x.ctrl":16,"n.ctrl":135,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Westman 1993","x.nrt":16,"n.nrt":78,"x.ctrl":2,"n.ctrl":80,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Wisborg 2000","x.nrt":19,"n.nrt":124,"x.ctrl":18,"n.ctrl":126,"treatment":"patch"}
{"study":"Hjalmarson 1997","x.nrt":35,"n.nrt":123,"x.ctrl":22,"n.ctrl":124,"treatment":"inhalator"}
{"study":"Leischow 1996a","x.nrt":12,"n.nrt":110,"x.ctrl":6,"n.ctrl":110,"treatment":"inhalator"}
{"study":"Schneider 1996","x.nrt":15,"n.nrt":112,"x.ctrl":9,"n.ctrl":111,"treatment":"inhalator"}
{"study":"Tonnesen 1993","x.nrt":22,"n.nrt":145,"x.ctrl":7,"n.ctrl":141,"treatment":"inhalator"}
{"study":"Blondal 1997","x.nrt":20,"n.nrt":79,"x.ctrl":13,"n.ctrl":78,"treatment":"intranasal spray"}
{"study":"Hjalmarson 1994","x.nrt":34,"n.nrt":125,"x.ctrl":18,"n.ctrl":123,"treatment":"intranasal spray"}
{"study":"Schneider 1995","x.nrt":23,"n.nrt":128,"x.ctrl":10,"n.ctrl":127,"treatment":"intranasal spray"}
{"study":"Sutherland 1992","x.nrt":30,"n.nrt":116,"x.ctrl":11,"n.ctrl":111,"treatment":"intranasal spray"}
{"study":"Dautzenberg 2001","x.nrt":25,"n.nrt":211,"x.ctrl":18,"n.ctrl":222,"treatment":"tablets/lozenges"}
{"study":"Fraser 2014","x.nrt":151,"n.nrt":518,"x.ctrl":139,"n.ctrl":516,"treatment":"tablets/lozenges"}
{"study":"Glover 2002","x.nrt":22,"n.nrt":120,"x.ctrl":12,"n.ctrl":121,"treatment":"tablets/lozenges"}
{"study":"Piper 2009","x.nrt":87,"n.nrt":260,"x.ctrl":8,"n.ctrl":36,"treatment":"tablets/lozenges"}
{"study":"Shiffman 2002 (2 mg)","x.nrt":82,"n.nrt":459,"x.ctrl":44,"n.ctrl":458,"treatment":"tablets/lozenges"}
{"study":"Shiffman 2002 (4 mg)","x.nrt":67,"n.nrt":450,"x.ctrl":28,"n.ctrl":451,"treatment":"tablets/lozenges"}
{"study":"Tonnesen 2006","x.nrt":26,"n.nrt":185,"x.ctrl":5,"n.ctrl":185,"treatment":"tablets/lozenges"}
{"study":"Wallstrom 2000","x.nrt":28,"n.nrt":123,"x.ctrl":19,"n.ctrl":124,"treatment":"tablets/lozenges"}
{"study":"Tonnesen 2012","x.nrt":44,"n.nrt":318,"x.ctrl":9,"n.ctrl":161,"treatment":"oral spray"}
{"study":"Graham 2017","x.nrt":366,"n.nrt":2630,"x.ctrl":312,"n.ctrl":2660,"treatment":"choice of product"}
{"study":"Johns 2017","x.nrt":27,"n.nrt":100,"x.ctrl":16,"n.ctrl":100,"treatment":"choice of product"}
{"study":"Kralikova 2009","x.nrt":39,"n.nrt":209,"x.ctrl":9,"n.ctrl":105,"treatment":"choice of product"}
{"study":"Molyneux 2003","x.nrt":10,"n.nrt":91,"x.ctrl":4,"n.ctrl":91,"treatment":"choice of product"}
{"study":"Ortega 2011","x.nrt":305,"n.nrt":924,"x.ctrl":193,"n.ctrl":919,"treatment":"choice of product"}
{"study":"Pollak 2007","x.nrt":24,"n.nrt":122,"x.ctrl":8,"n.ctrl":59,"treatment":"choice of product"}
{"study":"Wittchen 2011","x.nrt":22,"n.nrt":103,"x.ctrl":27,"n.ctrl":175,"treatment":"choice of product"}
{"study":"Hand 2002","x.nrt":20,"n.nrt":136,"x.ctrl":15,"n.ctrl":109,"treatment":"patch and inhalator"}
{"study":"Piper 2009","x.nrt":107,"n.nrt":267,"x.ctrl":9,"n.ctrl":41,"treatment":"patch and lozenge"}
{"study":"Hasan 2014","x.nrt":13,"n.nrt":40,"x.ctrl":15,"n.ctrl":41,"treatment":"patch and gum"}
{"study":"Stein 2013","x.nrt":11,"n.nrt":133,"x.ctrl":1,"n.ctrl":45,"treatment":"patch and gum"}
{"study":"Heydari 2013","x.nrt":15,"n.nrt":212,"x.ctrl":1,"n.ctrl":212,"treatment":"patch, gum, and lozenge"}